Then one day, I was browsing Michaels (like you do), and I found this amazing and adorable lazy Susan/carousel thing!
One bucket holds all the adhesive I use on a regular basis; tape runners, glue pens, liquid adhesive, and a small roll of foam tape. Specialized adhesive (like glue dots and my sticker maker) are in bins on my shelf - if I need them, I know where to find them.
Another bucket holds all my crafting tools. Several scissors, a bone folder, hole punch, poke tool, Quik-stix, X-acto knife, tweezers, and a brayer. These are tools I reach for very frequently. Again, the tools that I don't use often or that have a very specific purpose (like eyelet setter or a stapler) are in bins on my shelf.
I also have a mason jar with pens and markers. I don't have a lot of markers, so I only need the one jar.
So how do you store your tools? Is it working for you?
Happy Crafting (and organizing)!